My friend, you must have wasted more than half of your advertising budget...

My friend, you must have wasted more than half of your advertising budget...
A few days ago, I met a friend who worked on home fresh air systems on the high-speed rail.

He is a technical person and has a good understanding of air purification technology. Seeing that the air quality has been getting worse in recent years, he set up his own company specializing in home fresh air systems, hoping to get a share of the purification industry, which has basically become a red ocean.

We were just chatting, but when he found out that I was working in marketing , he immediately became interested and started asking me:

"What do you think I should do to advertise this product in residential elevators?"

Later I talked to him and got a general understanding of their promotion plan.

To be honest, while talking to him, John Wanamaker's words flashed through my mind at least 10 times - half of the money I spend on advertising is useless, but the problem is that I don't know which half.

And this sentence must be the voice of the friend who works on the fresh air system.

wrong.

In fact, this friend should be worse off, because he must have wasted more than half of his advertising money...

Wrong delivery location
Here I would like to give you a brief introduction: What is a "household fresh air purification system" (hereinafter referred to as the "fresh air system").
In fact, it is used to purify the air.

However, compared with common air purifiers (hereinafter referred to as "purifiers"), the fresh air system can not only purify the air, but also deliver fresh air to the room. (especially oxygen)

The purifier can only purify the air in the house but cannot provide fresh air.

In addition, installing a fresh air system can be troublesome because it requires the introduction of outside air, so a hole needs to be opened in the wall or window, and once installed it is difficult to move.

The purifier is very convenient. You can just buy it and put it anywhere.

Okay, now let's talk about advertising.

I would like to ask, where should I advertise a product like this for household use? (Since it involves door-to-door installation, offline advertising is mainly considered)

I think most people would choose the residential area.

After all, since it is a household product, it should be placed close to home, such as elevator advertisements in residential buildings and outdoor advertisements around residential areas. (That friend thought the same thing, he had already purchased elevator ads in several communities for two months)

However, should we really place advertisements in residential areas?

In fact, it is unscientific to do so...

First of all, not all people living in a community are landlords. Especially in communities close to the city center, a large proportion of them are tenants, and it is basically impossible for tenants to purchase this product.

Why?

As I said earlier, installing a fresh air system requires drilling holes in the wall or windows. Tenants will not easily or willingly remodel the room without the landlord's permission.

In addition, even if most of the residents in this community are landlords themselves, it is difficult to generate purchasing power - everything in my house has been renovated and the floor has been swept clean, and you have to come to my house and ask me to drill a hole or replace the glass or something, it is too much trouble!

Well, maybe you’re saying, “How much trouble can this be?”

In fact, the "laziness" of consumers is often beyond our imagination.

There is a psychology story like this:

One day, Person A complained to Person B, "Oh! It's so annoying. I've been eating tuna sandwiches for years. I feel like vomiting. Actually, my favorite thing is vegetable sandwiches, but I've never eaten them much."

Person B said, "Wow! How can your wife be like this? Can't she see through your needs and make you a vegetable sandwich?"

A said: "No, I don't have a wife. I have been making sandwiches myself all these years"...

Once consumers get used to certain behaviors or environments, it is difficult for them to change them, even if they know that the change is very beneficial to them.

This "mentality of not wanting to change" is actually the biggest enemy of all marketers - if consumers don't change, it means new products won't sell.

So, how can we activate consumers’ “mindset of change”?

When it comes to installing fresh air systems, the better way is not to persuade consumers to change, but to directly find out the state that consumers "want to change".

So under what circumstances do consumers want to change their homes?

The answer is obvious – when they are planning their future home.

When people plan for the future, they tend to think more rationally and be less afraid of trouble. (On this point, recall the goals you set for yourself at the beginning of each year, those goals that are difficult for ordinary people to achieve)

Therefore, the best place to advertise fresh air systems is not residential areas, but the home furnishing market, such as IKEA and Red Star Macalline, etc.

There, consumers will fantasize about how beautiful their future homes will be and how healthy their lives will be. They cannot tolerate living in a dirty environment in the future, so they are more likely to buy some "troublesome" products to satisfy their needs for a "perfect future."

(PS: Fresh air systems are generally targeted at more luxurious residences, and these customers are not short of money)

In addition, if you choose to advertise in such a place, you don’t need to spend effort telling consumers “I can provide door-to-door service” - because all the businesses here can provide this service. Once consumers come in, they will automatically assume that as long as the products they see here, they can be provided with door-to-door service.

This is called "borrowing power".

A small episode:
In fact, when I told that friend about my idea, he disagreed with my point of view at first. He said: "My product is mainly used after decoration, so, should I let others see this advertisement after decoration?"

I said to him, "Look, the range hood, air conditioner, toilet, bed, which one is not used after the renovation? But aren't most of them purchased during the renovation period..."

Wrong delivery time
Shi Yuzhu mentioned in his book that when he was advertising Melatonin, he did it in the form of "pulses":
The peak seasons for Melatonin are the Mid-Autumn Festival and the Spring Festival.

As long as more children come home, it is our peak season.

After all, not most children live with their parents nowadays. Most people go home to visit their parents and mother-in-law during the Spring Festival. This is our peak season.

During the Spring Festival alone, which lasts for about 10 days a week, our sales account for 50% of our annual sales. So at this time our ads will be very concentrated and annoying.

You won’t be able to find our advertisements after the Spring Festival.

So although our advertisements give people the impression that there are a lot, in fact the money and advertising fees we spend are not that much, and we are not even in the top 50 in terms of the total amount. Our total volume is not large.

——Excerpt from "Shi Yuzhu's Autobiography: My Marketing Experience"

Melatonin is a seasonal product, and so are the fresh air system and purifier - when the haze comes in winter, that's when people's demand for purified air is the highest.

Data source : Baidu Index
As for my friend who worked on the fresh air system, he started to put it into use in early September, which was obviously two months early.

Therefore, the advertising fee for these two months is basically wasted...

(PS, some people on the Internet say that the peak season for renovation is concentrated from September to November, but this is mainly due to humidity factors, and the northern region is generally dry, so this is not the point)

No competitive advantage
Now let’s take a look at what this friend’s ad looks like:
The coded area is the contact information
Let’s ignore the strong “print shop design style” of this advertisement (after all, as a technical person, he doesn’t know much about aesthetics and composition), and just look at the message it conveys.

When we analyze a print advertisement, the most important thing is to see "what will consumers see at first glance? What will they think of next?"

What is the first thing you see in the picture above? (Take at most three seconds to read)

Of course, it was the words “smog is coming”, a picture of a “house section”, and a price of “1488”.

So what will these pieces of information make consumers think of?

1) When seeing the words “smog is coming”, most consumers may think: Yes, smog is coming, what should I do?

After waiting for two seconds, he had another idea: Yes! Maybe I should buy an air purifier (instead of a fresh air system) - smog is no longer a new topic, and people have already found solutions - using purifiers at home and masks outside. 2) When seeing the “house cross-section” picture, consumers may further think: Yes, I should buy a purifier so that my family can enjoy a healthy life.

Although the fresh air system appears in the picture, it is too inconspicuous. Most people lack relevant professional knowledge and they would not be so sensitive to an "unknown object" hanging on the wall.

In comparison, the four faces are more eye-catching.

3) When consumers see the price of “1488” which is neither too high nor too low, they have no other thoughts because they have already made their choice – either buy a purifier or buy nothing.

4) As for other information, there is no need to look at it.

If the main information of the advertisement cannot attract consumers' attention, how can we expect them to carefully study other secondary information?

Especially in the elevator, the time is too short.

Therefore, the content of this advertisement is basically in vain...

So what should we do?
We chatted for more than an hour on the high-speed train. Along the way, I told him a lot about the unreasonable aspects of this advertisement, and even talked about some psychology knowledge...

Later we exchanged WeChat accounts , and I promised to help him improve his advertising.

However, the address and time of the advertisement cannot be changed for the time being, because he has already purchased the community elevator advertisement for two months and he can't just waste it. (We will consider advertising in Home Furnishing City later)

Here are the specific improvements I made:

1. Product name:

"Fresh air purification system" is actually a relatively unfamiliar concept, and the "system" gives people a feeling of complexity and trouble.

My suggestion is: change the product name to "Fresh Air Purifier" - to establish a connection with the well-known "air purifier";

2. Main copy : Smog is not a new topic, and people have long been motivated to purify the air, so there is no need to emphasize it again.

The focus should be on the advantage of the fresh air system over the purifier - the ability to deliver fresh air.

However, the product attributes alone do not have strong appeal. We should also transform them into consumer benefits - even without opening the windows, we can still enjoy fresh air.

3. Sub-copy: Since holes need to be drilled, it is necessary to reduce consumers' concerns - free door-to-door installation;

Since it is a new product, it is necessary to reduce consumers’ perceived risk of product features – try it for free for 30 days and return it if not satisfied.

(PS, “free trial” was a promotional plan I thought of later. As long as users have tried the product, they generally will not return it because they have already paid a higher cost - opening a hole in the window/wall.) In addition, the price of 1488 itself is meaningless. Rich people will never think it is too little, and poor people will never think it is too much.

It should be compared to competing products - cheaper than air purifiers, more natural and healthier. (Imported purifiers on the market are generally more than 2,000)

This is the only way to highlight the value of the price.

4. Product details: It is difficult for consumers to buy an unfamiliar product based on an advertisement, but it is also difficult for consumers to learn more detailed information in the elevator.

Therefore, a QR code leading to the product details page (including contact information) should be added.

If conditions permit, the advertising frame can also be modified - add a small pocket under the frame, which contains the product manual. If consumers are interested, they can pick up a copy and read it slowly at home.

5. Picture section:

A photo of an actual case, or a good 3D rendering, as a large background.

A cross-sectional diagram is also required, but it should be made into a small diagram and placed at a secondary level.

Below is my draft: (Actually it’s the finished product. I didn’t have time to do the pictures and layout, so I just found a random picture as the background)

Well, let's compare again:

As an elevator advertisement, the composition structure must be clear and the advertising information must have a sense of hierarchy so that consumers can read more efficiently.
Other suggestions
Finally, there are some sporadic free suggestions, which are not very relevant to this advertising, but are also quite important: 1. Brand name and logo

The brand name ELIKON has no meaning. Consumers need to spend at least half a minute to think carefully before they can figure out its meaning. So, it is just pretending to be fashionable and catchy...

The idea of ​​the LOGO is pretty good. (Of course, there is still a lot of room for improvement in terms of aesthetics)

In fact, the brand name can be called "Three Trees"/"Three Pines"/"Three Songs", etc. This will not only make people think of "fresh air" or even "family", but more importantly: these names are visual and very easy to understand and remember. 2. Improve perceived value

Since air quality is difficult for the human body to perceive, a PM2.5 detector can be given to each trial user. Through the data on the detector, he can "really" feel that the air has indeed become fresher.

3. Product level

As I said earlier, fresh air systems are generally suitable for relatively luxurious residences. Therefore, the appearance and craftsmanship of the product also need to be considered. (Don’t worry too much about the cost. The price of 1488 is relatively low even for an air purifier, and there is still a lot of room for improvement.)

After all, what consumers buy is not the "fresh air system" machine, but their yearning for a better family life.

The artistic conception of this concept product is very good, and it even has a bit of the flavor of a work of art. (Go to Pinterest, Behance and other websites)

In short, we must try our best to improve the entire system. Because for any product to be successful, there must be no fatal weaknesses in every link.

Advertising cannot directly solve sales problems; it is only one part of the marketing mix.

The weaknesses in every other link will make the advertisement ineffective to a certain extent.

The author of this article @品牌圈圈 Xiao Yunzi compiled and published by (Qinggua Media). Please indicate the author information and source when reprinting!

Product promotion services: APP promotion services, information flow advertising, advertising platform

<<:  Short video emotional communication project, a way to make money in the niche field

>>:  WeChat public account interception technology, simple operation to earn 670 yuan a day!

Recommend

“BabyTree” user growth case analysis!

Against the backdrop of the gradual decline of tr...

Practical techniques for obtaining effective traffic in early Internet startups!

Practical methods for obtaining effective traffic ...

Regarding community operation, I have 5 routines here!

Group administrator: @李根同学, please do not post ad...

How to configure e-commerce game server rental

The game e-commerce platform is a field that many...

Sina Fuyi Mobile Game Industry Launch Strategy

The mobile game market seems to be booming, but m...

How to write good copy? Here are 6 tips for you!

Today we are going to talk about copywriting . Wh...

Principal Lao Li's Live Room 2021

Principal Lao Li's live broadcast room 2021 r...

How to determine whether a website’s traffic is fake?

Judging whether a website relies on inflating tra...

Summary of high-quality marketing channels for APP promotion!

In recent years, the frequency of use of mobile a...

Analysis of the "Fan Deng Reading" activity

The case analysis brought to you today is Fan Den...